Jump to content
Post-Update: Forum Issues Read more... ×
BPAL Madness!

RoseThornAndOak

Members
  • Content Count

    712
  • Joined

  • Last visited

2 Followers

About RoseThornAndOak

  • Rank
    sexy swapper

BPAL

  • BPAL of the Day
    The Woman Behind It
  • Favorite Scents
    Lady of Saintonge, Blossoms, Pink Snowballs, Lycan Lace, Raven Moon 2012, Ava, Awake, Inez, Lyonesse, Snow-Flakes, Tattered Lace, Thalassa, Liz, Theodosius, Lady of Shalott, Pele, Rose Red, Glittering Apple of The Stars, Yvaine, Lullaby, Dark Lace, No Man is An Island, Snow White, Mrs Wilson, Gobo, Snow at Dawn, Last Unicorn, Gingerbread and Leather, Twisted Oak Tree, Grey Columns, A Spirit Katie, Snow-covered Landscape, Winter Night Figure on a Bridge, Mouses Long and Sad Tale, Coyote, Two Women on Veranda Overlooking The Sea, An Opiate Vapor, Zorya P, Spring, Lune Debonnaire, Lavender Brownie, Tea Leaves Vanilla Bean & Incense Smoke

Profile Information

  • Mood
    Uchi uchi thirsty

Astrology

  • Astrological Info
    0
  • Chinese Zodiac Sign
    Nothing Selected
  • Western Zodiac Sign
    Nothing Selected

Location

  • Country
    United States

Recent Profile Visitors

5,263 profile views
  1. RoseThornAndOak

    Midwinter's Eve

    2018 version: cinnamon plum forward, with soft, chilly florals in the background (not indolic or powdery). It is prettier on my hair and fabrics instead of on the skin, though it's still a keeper. A splendid Winter blend, and it would work well in Autumn and early Spring.
  2. RoseThornAndOak

    Caramel Apple Cookie 2025 Hair Gloss

    Oof yeah this is the stuff. This is more or less the same as the perfume oil, sweet cinnamon apple gooey yumminess! Caramel can go plasticky on me but here it works. Same with sugar notes, but brown sugar doesn't and goes more like the molassas note, which I'm appreciative of as many of the cookie/sugar blends just go a little plasticky, too. Here, it works. There is a pumpkin apple cinnamon candle vibe but honestly, candles have come a long way over the years, and many translate well on the skin or hair, so whatevs. It is like what your hair would smell like if you had an apple candle going. I think the perfume oil goes a bit more cookie, this goes a tad more apple. This is so yummy and sexy. I think a decant is enough given how often I reach for hair gloss, but like dear Eve I am tempted, annnnnd now have God Dethroned stuck in my head til further notice. Eve take a bite (fear not) Eve you're a god (the poison apple) Eve you're divine (you're a god) You won't fall from grace (the poison apple) Forbidden fruit (oh eve) it's so good for you (the poison apple) ❤
  3. RoseThornAndOak

    Headless Hearsemen

    SmellsPrettyGood2Me and I are of like-mind on the whole hoping the dead leaf note won't slide into our DMs like it does, but yep, that's exactly what it done did. This is heavy dead leaves, and darkness and decay, with dark sinister spices and none more black leather. The drydown is mostly a dark vetiver. Does it fit the vibe? I mean, yeah. There are others that make me feel more like I am in Sleepy Hollow, though. Oddly, I'm really enjoying the dead leaves opening more than the woodsy drydown? Can some esplaing? Is anomaly? I think it would layer well with Sidewalk Apples though, for a cemetery in Sleepy Hollow vibe, at least in the decants, although I don't think the drydowns would flesh out that way. I think a decant is enough for me, but we'll see. Honestly I'm just pining for Katrina and the rest of the Sleepy Hollow line to come back and filling in the time til it does. If we all together think it will come back, will it come to pass? Like the Order of The Dragons, I summon thee to return! Lol.
  4. RoseThornAndOak

    The Woman Behind It

    I agree this is very Evening With The Spirits in atmosphere. I get a pale ghost of florals like if a spirit was trapped in a powder puff. A friend and I came up with a bunch of silly spoopy song names for this project that never came to be like Elegant in Darkness and Mournique, and this kinda reminds me of both. It's all funerals, and ghosts, and old houses. It's a little too powdery at first, but that drydown I can get down with. Floral and pretty and soft.
  5. RoseThornAndOak

    Pumpkin Popcorn

    Okay, you know when pumpkin smells kind of fruity, almost like orange or mango but you can't really place what fruit it is other than pumpkin fruit? That's what I get here, plus sweet 'n buttery popcorn, and a dash of spice. Similar to Mouse Circus, a tad less sweet but more pumpkin spice type sweet. I like it! It's fun and playful. This is the Harvest Haunt's gf, like, Haunt's trying to be all dark and broody and stuff, and Pumpkin Popcorn is making funny faces in the photos and is more Devil-may-care in life, and he lowkey misses her charm when she's not around. It's very Carnival Diabolique in Autumn.
  6. RoseThornAndOak

    Sidewalk Apples

    I didn't expect to like this one as much as I do! It's heavy on the dead leaves as first, with petrichorish sidewalk and some apple. However, this take a turn for the better, smelling more and more like a cemetery in autumn with apples on the ground. At first, it's very much like the scents October and November, but less cold, and also reminds me of the blend St Louis Cemetery. The sidewalk note really does bring to mind the old cemeteries we have here on the East Coast. Although there is a petrichor vibe, this is quite a dry blend overall. I think if you like many of the 'PAL's or other indie cemetery blends, you'll like this one. Layered with a dark rainy blend like leather + rain, you'd have an atmosphere like The Crow with blustering leaves, sorrow, and vengeance on the wind. I'm considering a bottle, yet this is much more of a room scent for me.
  7. RoseThornAndOak

    Nag Champa?

    @Assimbya pretty much nailed it @sudenmorsian. Champaca - reads like a big white floral, a bit nocturnal, can be powdery, with a bit of incense in the wind, but not smoky. It has a depth to it that some florals don't have. Champaca comes off as pretty, sexy, and glamourous to me. Nag champa - somewhat musky, dry incense dust that can have a powdery element but is much less floral. It can sometimes read a bit floral, but I feel like it has even more dimension than champaca as it usually has magnolia champaca and/or fragingpani, and sandalwoods in it's composition. Nag champa comes off as nostalgic, arcane, and mysterious.
  8. RoseThornAndOak

    Every Day is Halloween

    2022 version: This year is a cozy, spiced, Autumn sandalwood with a bit of skin musk. This is the type of sandalwood that goes dry, yet sweet. I get less wine notes than 2021, but both years are nice. Beautiful.
  9. RoseThornAndOak

    Dangers Untold

    This is a beautiful white floral. The florals are pale and powdered in a classic, yet whimsical sort of way. The white taffeta is nothing like Black Taffeta, if you have tried it. It is similar, but not quite like the silk note, which has a distinctive, almost fruity sweetness to it. I get more of a smooth note binding everything together (no plastic notes as well) that conjures images of fine, white satin gloves you would wear to a ball, which is fitting. This is nothing like a linen or cotton note, either (so no laundry vibes). There is a somewhat aldehydic note, without the soda bubbles, and just the smooth high notes. I was expecting something similar to Silver Phoenix, but SP is quite more metallic. This reminds me most of: - Young Woman Powdering Herself - less gardenia - Datura Blossom - less purple and vegetal - Moonshine & Mist - less mist - White Silk Crysanthenum - less bubbles and spice - Razors in a Doll's House - less cognac or vanilla lace type, more the floral + silver aspect - Tovenares - less rose and bones - Leanan Sidhe - less mist I know powdery scents get a lot of hate, but this is one that I love. It's fresh, clean, classic, elegant, and ethereal. It perfectly fits Sarah floating around in the white ballgown.
  10. RoseThornAndOak

    Deathrock

    I like this. It reminds me of Liz with a dark leather and soft, cool, vanilla tone. I find Liz more floral, Deathrock more resinous with the styrax and benzoin. It's a moody, slightly more traditionally masculine blend that doesn't smell like cigarette smoke to me. There is a tiny bit of hairspray, but perhaps with age, the resins have smoothed out the harshness that would come of those note and made this more like a soft leather to my nose. Overall, this is really nice and I'm happy Liz has a boyfriend to sit next to now.
  11. RoseThornAndOak

    The Human Double

    This is a nice gentlemen's fougere, leaning aquatic and green, the lavender not too herbal or heady, but perfectly placed as it usually is amongst fougeres. I don't get much of the 🎸blackened! 🎸 aspect, but there is something to this that reads refined, traditional men's cologne but they placed noir at the end of the name, without any strong chemical oud, patchouli, or black musk note. Just a hint of something dark and sinister. Maybe this is an elf in Middle Earth, freshly pierced by an arrow, consciousness fading into the void. Or Lawrence Talbot, dark-haired, all cleaned up and normal presenting, hiding terrible secrets. Very well done, a nice vintage type blend yet not in an outdated way. It's still available as of today and I'm glad I went for it.
  12. RoseThornAndOak

    The King's Daughter

    I get the crisp dry rind parts of watermelon, not so much the juicy, fruity bits, lilac musk to soften and alas cedar/pencil shavings, then it fades fast.
  13. RoseThornAndOak

    Hamlet et les Fossoyeurs

    I get soft, mossy, fougere green notes and dry woods that go regretably sharp on me for a while then chill out and soften. Room scent for me.
  14. RoseThornAndOak

    Rose Milk Tea

    It's nice. I do get a pinkish type rose for a while, but the milk and starchy rice take over after a while. The milk is similar to the one in Mummy and Vampire Milk on me, tangy like the goat's milk note. Not as strong, but present. I wish the rose came out more, but I tend to amp this milk note. Forgot this was a tea blend, honestly. I think I picked up some in the beginning but I must've drank it all up because now it's all froth.
  15. RoseThornAndOak

    Jolly Roger

    If I ever upped the Jolly Roger in open battle it was oe'r 10-15 years ago, I reckon, and my memory of the incident was very mimimal. Actually yeah I wasn't there and it wasn't me. I get all of the notes listed. The sea spray is fresh and salty, not too murky. The leather and rum are smoothed and aged beautifully. The rum is indeed bay rum, but not sharp in anyway as it can on occasion go (put your cutlass away, sir!) but does have that clean herbal edge to it. The woods are warmed in the sun and I couldn't tell you what they are. If you like driftwood as a note, you'll likely like the wood in this. I love Mary Read so much, and this one is very similar, without the gunpowder and sarsprilla. Love love love.
×