Love: Lavender (all surrounded with hearts and stars), leather, linden, water, ozone, carnation, lilac and stargazer lily (the last two not so much in BPAL though, it seems). Mysterious Warning, Casanova, Envy, Aziraphale, Yvaine and Tristran, Cordelia, Jazz Funeral, Herr Drosselmeyer, Jolly Roger, Toad Hall, and Hunter are among my favorites that I've tried. I prefer the androgynous or more "masculine" scents to the girlier ones in general.
The Dragon's Blood stuff is a total dealbreaker for me, but I also don't love wearing terribly obvious florals, and most rose tends to go that way on me. The "incense-y" type scents are also not often my cup of tea, but I'll occasionally find a use for them.