doomsday_disco Report post Posted December 2, 2025 A BPAL favorite since 2005, affectionately nicknamed ‘The Devil’s Bake Sale.’ Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
AnOfferingToTheNight Report post Posted December 26, 2025 This is such a warm, golden scent. Like, straight from the oven warm. Buttery, vanilla, sugary goodness. I bought this for a friend and I really wanted to take a bite of her arm when she put this on. I can see why this a favorite for so many people! If you or someone you love goes hard for gourmands, it really doesn't get better than this. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
doomsday_disco Report post Posted June 16 I blind bottled this in my Yule order and am only just now getting around to reviewing this, after testing the lotion on one hand and the perfume oil on another this weekend. This has the same syrupy sweetness as the Lab's Sugar Cookie scent, but it lacks the toastiness of the perfume version. You can tell that they're the same scent that varies somewhat depending on the medium, since the perfume version has more of that baked good warmth to it. That said, I'm still happy to have a bottle of this lotion in my collection and look forward to pairing it not only with Sugar Cookie perfume oil, but with other cookie scents. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
