Treat #2, Snow Angel, Lick It, and Shub Niggurath are my four can't-decide-between-them favorites. I also like Pumpkin Patch #5, Siren, Dana O'Shee, Eden, Harvest Moon (2005), Mi-Go Brain Canister, Fruit Moon, Hungry Ghost Moon, Eat Me, and Dorian.
Fig is a particular favorite, and smells great on my skin. I like sweet florals and anything with pumpkin. Milk and honey are great notes for me, as are roses, violets, and pear. I love tea scents but they sometimes smell like Lemon Pledge on me. I like red musk and light musks a lot, but it's hit or miss if it smells good on my skin. White musk usually does. Darker musks sometimes work, but usually don't.
Alice, Two, Five & Seven, and Maiden all depressed me when they didn't work.
Leather, grass, carnation, tobacco leaf, chocolate/cocoa, and patchouli are all bad notes, especially the first two - leather smells like rotting cow and grass smells like chemically treated lawn on my skin. :(