Ecto-coolest

I think mine needs a longer rest, but so far I get a nice aftershave or Dial soap scent from this. I was hoping for more smoke and beeswax, but maybe those will reveal themselves on a longer wear test. Update: it has mellowed out and the beeswax and smoke have become more noticeable. As a smoke note fiend I do still wish there was a little more birch tar, but overall I really enjoy this scent!

Hi all! I'm relatively new to indie perfumes and have found I'm incredibly fond of birch tar and woodsmoke notes. I am in search of the smokiest, least sweet scents BPAL (and possibly other brands) have. Current smoky favorites are Morari's Am I the Baddie?, Heretic Poltergeist (I know it isn't indie but it has the BEST non sweet birch tar I've found yet), and For Strange Women Fireside Story. I have heard Krampus' Shadow is good but discontinued.

My friend decanted some of Hearthflame and Incense for me and it's been very good to me so far! I'll have to look into Witches Burn back thank you! I'll have to keep my eyes out for those in the swaps! I've tried some other brands pine pitch notes and really enjoyed them, but not any burgundy pitch notes yet. Thank you for the leads!