Surprisingly, I enjoy Athens immensely. I bought the imp with my boyfriend in mind, as he prefers sweeter and more traditionally feminine scents than I do, and so I wasn't expecting to be so keen on it.
I was, indeed, quite stunned by my immediate enthrallment by the first sniff of the imp: it was overpoweringly sweet, more so than I had imagined. And yet, even within the imp, there was a certain tartness to this sweetness, a shadow of red wine, that had to be chased, and which I found absolutely tantalising. It is what makes this scent sweet, but not girlish. That slight bitterness, in fact, divided me and my boyfriend on this scent - I loved the red wine, he not so much.
Upon application, Athens is almost an entirely different story for me: frankincense steals the show, with honey and wine now as the accompaniments. It is still sweet and quite mysterious, but it remind me more of a temple, with burning incense and libations, than honey. Quite another surprise this transformation, but not an unwelcome one; the scent wet is more suited for momentary olfactory enjoyment than wearing, in my opining, thus its drastic change makes it a better candidate for perfume purposes.