agentcat

The butter in Jack, Sugar Cookie and Gluttony turns into microwave popcorn fake butter smell on me.

Yes! This is exactly it! I thought I was crazy because I don't know anybody else who has the same reaction I do to the smell of microwave buttered popcorn.

Yikes, what a shame. I really wish these ones would work on me.

Can anyone recommend any other foody scents that don't have this effect!

or know if I might be lucky with Gingerbread Poppet. I have all my appendages crossed that this one will be re-released in the next Yule update and that it will work for me!

Many thanks, you guys are awesome.

I'm fairly new to BPAL so I'm still trying out a lot of new scents but there is a note that my nose just does not get along with in a number of the scents I want so desperately to love. I'm hoping someone might be able to help pinpoint what it might be.

It is in many of the foody or sweet scents I've tried. I LOVE Midway and Dorian but there's something horrible in Gluttony, Jack, Sugar Cookie and a couple of others -

I'll add the rest of the names when I go home an re-sniff my collection!

Could it be a milky note, or a butter note or something?

What do you think?

Any recommendations of what else I might be able to try to isolate that note? Anyone have similar experiences?

Thanks!