Currently, these are my favourite 5ml bottles. I'd take imps or decants of any of these scents, and back up bottles of the starred:

Creepy 2009 (low)

Boo 2010

Golletes

Pumpkin Latte

smut 2010

womb furie

Lawn Gnome*

VILF

Miskatonic University*

al-azif

Midnight on the Midway

The Illustrated Woman

Mme. Moriarty, Misfortune Teller

Midnight Bell

Devil's Night 2009

Dia de los Muertes 2009

Trick or Treat 2009* (low!)

Banned in Boston*

enyalios

olisbos

Ronin

TOMBEUR* (low!)