Alshneato

Has anyone tried Mr. Nancy and found it very cookie-like?

 

Sugar cookies with bay rum, tobacco, and lime.

I have a decant of Mr Nancy and I found it to be spicy lime sugar cookies at first, a little tobacco for a minute, but not over powering, then spicy cookies in the dry down. I don't like tobacco or bay rum really and I am looking for a bottle of Mr Nancy- it is lovely!

My bottle smells like cologne- I was hoping for the buttery lavender cheesecake everyone is talking about!

ETA- I have now tried a decant that was supposed to be the more lavender cheesecake version- I still didn't get any cheesecake out of it!! Not for me I guess.

ETAA- I now have a bottle of the cheesecake version- thanks to the extremely generous and lovely emzebel to whom I will forever be grateful!! I LOVE this sooooo much! :love!:

ETAAA- This one is in my top ten! I wear it to bed every night- as well as during the day sometimes- it is so creamy and well balanced and just perfect!!

I love this one too! All the sweet fruits are delightful and the dry down is all cotton candy musk!! YUM!

Oh I was so hoping for coconut and black licorice!! On my skin this smells like tobacco!

So neat!! I can really smell the pine and the cotton candy!! I like it but the BF doesn't

ETA- Who do I have to BEG to get this without the pine??

This is perfection! Smells exactly as described to me!!

I LOVE this one!! On me I get all pink sugar and marshmallow!!

At first sniff I thought it smelled just like Lambs Wool- so I put Autumn Cider on one wrist and Lambs Wool on the other. Man oh man I love this stuff!! I loved Lambs Wool but this is BETTER! It has a lot of orange, and it is fizzy to my nose, and a lot of cinnamon. I just adore it and I am glad I got a bottle- the label is too cute as well

ETA- I would love to smell a version of this one with out the spices, it is so fruity!!

I LOVE this!! It really smells like Funfetti cake to me!!

ETA: I currently have 2 bottles of this- one smells like cake and fruity rainbow sprinkles. The other smells like chocolate cupcakes with vanilla frosting. They are VERY different from each other!!

ETA ETA: I have had 6 bottles of this- 3 of which I kept, the 3 that smell fruity- the other 3 were the chocolatey ones. All 3 of each variation smelled exactly alike, so there is definitely 2 versions of this!!!

Wet this smells so similar to NGAGL5 to me. I almost regretted swapping for this one after I read the reviews- but I am beyond happy with it!!

I have-

Vanilla CT 245- watermelon hard candy- TDF!! with a tangy cream...

I have had but no longer do-

Vanilla CT 103- smokey vanilla cake

Vanilla CT 325- apricots and cream

Vanilla CT 33- plum pina colada cream touch of honey

Vanilla CT 406- vanilla cake frosting light musk

Vanilla CT 683- orange mango bubble gum cake

Vanilla CT 702- musk from Teatime in Roswell some light fruit

Vanilla CT 24- gingerbread musk

Vanilla CT 620- candy candy candy and then a floral note that reminds me of J Horror and Tiki v3

Vanilla CT 316- amazing honeydew melon and vanilla combo!

Vanilla CT 591- strawberry vanilla

Vanilla CT 631- Anti-Saloon with a creamier vanilla??

Very lovely- the best wine scent I have tried so far!!

This one is one of my favorites! I love the strawberry cake and the carnation adds a delicate spice! TDF!!

To me this smells like burnt sugar- very sad because I wanted to love it so much! Great label though- glad I found an empty bottle

I love this one- very tangy sharp grapefruit and green musk!

Sweet and spicy- I really like this one a lot- I do wish it was less peppery.... love the label too!

My #1, I have 3 bottles, I adore this scent. To me it is bubble gum at first, then it becomes the perfect vanilla frosting. The dry down reminds me of sweet iced tea- though I do not believe there is a tea note in it. It's just comforting!!

Very fizzy- I can smell the apples but this turns into soap on me... my BF loves it though!!

This is so lovely!! Orange and vanilla frosting! One of my go to scents!!

I also agree with the Starburst assessment- but there is something green or floral in the background that I amped like crazy and this didn't work for me

I had high hopes for this one. Sadly I too had the soapy experience with this one.

I am on the fence with this one. It does smell like blueberry, but from afar..... I was hoping for a nice strong blueberry note. I may not keep my bottle.

I love this so so much!! It is all red hard candy on me! It actually reminds me of kool-aid powder, the kind the comes pre-sugared