creepy

at first it was too strong but then it turned into a rich cardamom cake- nice!

so sad this doesn't smell like coffee at all to me, the description sounds perfect, but it smells harsh and cheap-cologne-y on me:(! hurt my nose and my head.

so sad, was all excited about this one but it just smells like apple cider with a bit of pumpkin. no cream at all.

edit- its a decent smell, just not what i was hoping for.

when its wet i get a bitter smell above a musky tobacco smell- its not pleasant to me. after its dry though, it smells like play-doh! i guess thats this powder people are talking about. well i love play-doh, so its not a bad thing, at all. i was disappointed with demeter's version of play-doh so this kinda makes up for it. still debating buying a bottle though, i dont know how many times i want to smell like kids clay.

i'm sad cuz the description sounded perfect to me, and in the bottle it smelled great- but on me it smells like a fake vanilla candle. and then it smells better for a few minutes, and back to fake vanilla candle. i hope in an hour or so it smells delicious, cuz i bought a whole bottle:(

i'm thinking it might smell fairly awesome layered with the milk chocolate buttercream scent.

2009 version

ive only tried this version, so nothing to compare it to. it has a bit of candy corn smell to it, but really it smells like maple syrup. i think of it as "IHOP" oil. i like it, and love it when i put it on with a touch of one of the chocolate scents(i'm a candy fiend!).

now i want to track down the older ones...