[OctoberGwen]

Thick, sugared and bloated with sweetness. Dark chocolate, vanilla, buttercream, and hops with pralines, hazelnut, toffee and caramel.

Hmmmmm......I almost love this, but there is a note in here that goes strongly tobacco-like on my skin. I suspect it's either the hazelnut or the buttercream, because the same thing happened with Hellcat (only worse.) It's probably the hazelnut, but I shall have to investigate this further.

[Fetish911]

In the imp and wet this is the most delicious chocolatey deliciousness.... on dry down this is the most disgusting dry, spicy, yet ranicd, bitter cocoa on me with a little dirt thrown in. It was making me nauseus everytime I caught a whiff. Which really sux cause it started off amazing.
I was so happy to wash this one off.

[Gateau]

I was so excited to try this, and it started out wonderfully rich and toffee-like, but as I wore it I got a strong leafy tobacco, oaky Scotch, cologne sort of vibe. Looks like I'm not alone in that.

[sharkdiver]

This smells like gigantic burnt awful FAIL on me...I have a decant from a lovely forumite, and It's gonna go straight to the swap pile, without passing go! I actually had to go wash it off, and then try to mask the awfulness with the Malignant dreams of Cthulu in love...but I can still smell it :cry2:

[Lailya]

The ever-awesome Catalyst sent me an imp of this and it smelled wonderful! Chocolatey toffee, mmm, yummy.

Once it hit my skin, though, it turned ugly. The hops suddenly came out and turned a too-sweet rancid, if that makes sense, and overpowered everything. :( Very sad, because I love foody scents and Gluttony sounded amazing. Curse you, skin chemistry!

This post has been edited by Lailya: 14 June 2012 - 02:53 PM

[KittyHawk]

Blech, boozy almond and praline. This isn't quite as bad as Hellcat, but it's close. I was really hoping for a rich, decadent chocolate and buttercream here, but it's just a generic sickening sweetness. Obviously, since Gluttony was discontinued some time ago, I'm curious what this would smell like fresh. Better, perhaps. All the same, I can say with certainty that Gluttony is not my deadly sin. Lust it is. ;)

[whitsunweddings]

In the imp: A sweet, slightly spiced, nutty wonderfulness.
Wet: Hmm, chocolate and hazelnut. Not at all like Nutella, surprisingly.
Dry: Kinda funky on me, actually. Still making me mightily peckish.
10 minutes later: Funkiness vanished, now just a lovely sweet hazelnut.

[neuilly]

So yummy!! It's certainly very indulgent just as the name suggests. I get more pralines and toffee than anything else, but it's a very rich scent. I get a lot of "browns" in it.